Discuss the reasons for the limited success of Panchayati Raj Institutions in India. Also, recommend measures to strengthen the functioning of these institutions.
Based on 20 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.
What most aspirants missed
- Gram Sabha as the accountability mechanism and its empowerment through regular meetings and social audits
- Only a fraction of the 29 Eleventh Schedule subjects transferred, with inadequate activity mapping, and why this matters in practice
- Non-functional District Planning Committees under Article 243ZD and the need to activate them
- Irregular constitution of State Finance Commissions under Article 243I and the resulting fund starvation
- Political interference by MLAs and MPs and parallel bodies such as DRDAs bypassing PRIs
- PESA 1996 enforcement for tribal areas, with concrete success examples such as Hiware Bazar or Kerala
Common mistakes
- Listing reasons without explaining how each one actually weakens PRIs, such as repeating finance points in different words
- Giving generic recommendations like more funds or more awareness without naming schemes, provisions or models
- Including benefits of PRIs or long background, which uses up word space meant for reasons and measures
- Making unverified or wrongly stated claims about states' powers, such as rescinding elected bodies, which Article 243E does not allow
What the better answers did
- Clear split into reasons and measures with headings, and each reason linked to a constitutional provision or report
- Specific examples such as Kerala's People's Plan Campaign, Rajasthan social audits, Hiware Bazar or the Second ARC recommendations
- Addressing social factors like elite capture and Sarpanch Pati alongside structural and financial reasons
- A concluding line that ties the answer back to the 3Fs and Gram Sabha accountability
Introduction
Open by stating that the 73rd Amendment created the framework but states have not devolved the 3Fs, which sets up the whole answer.
Conclusion
Close by linking the 3Fs and Gram Sabha accountability to the reform measures, with one success example such as Kerala or Hiware Bazar.
Model answer
Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) received constitutional status through the 73rd Amendment (1992), with Part IX and the Eleventh Schedule listing 29 subjects. In practice, many Panchayats function as implementing agencies of state departments rather than as self-governing bodies.
Reasons for limited success
- Incomplete devolution of the 3Fs: Most states have transferred only a fraction of the 29 Eleventh Schedule subjects. Activity mapping is inadequate, so PRIs lack clear domains and funds do not follow functions.
- Weak finances: PRIs raise very little own revenue. State Finance Commissions under Article 243I are constituted irregularly, and their recommendations are often ignored, leaving PRIs dependent on tied grants.
- Parallel bodies and state control: DRDAs and line departments, with BDOs often dominating Sarpanches, bypass elected bodies. Political interference by MLAs and MPs, and irregular State Election Commission functioning, further weaken autonomy.
- Elite capture and social barriers: Caste and class dominance, illiteracy and Sarpanch Pati culture, where husbands or male relatives control elected women, limit real participation.
- Capacity gaps: Many Gram Panchayats lack secretaries and engineers, and elected members often cannot prepare development plans.
Measures to strengthen PRIs
- Mandatory activity mapping of the 29 subjects and transfer of functions, functionaries and funds, as recommended by the Second ARC.
- Regular constitution of State Finance Commissions and performance-linked grants on Finance Commission recommendations, with taxation powers under Article 243H.
- Activate District Planning Committees under Article 243ZD to integrate Panchayat plans into district plans.
- Strengthen Gram Sabhas through regular meetings and social audits, as in Rajasthan. Use GPDP for participatory planning, as Kerala's People's Plan Campaign showed.
- Enforce PESA, 1996 in Scheduled Areas, build capacity through RGPSA, and use e-Gram Swaraj for transparent accounts.
PRIs will succeed only when functions, funds and functionaries move together, and when Gram Sabhas hold the institutions accountable. Hiware Bazar and Kerala show that local ownership works when the state commits to real devolution.
Write this answer and get it evaluated
Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.
Evaluate my answerMore GS Paper 2 questions
- The 103rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019 has introduced a new dimension to the principle of affirmative action in India. Critically examine its implications for the broader goal of social justice.
- What constitutes corrupt practices under the Representation of the People Act, 1951? Also, discuss the challenges in curbing such malpractices and suggest remedial measures.
- Discuss the role of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in the development of developing countries. What are the key criticisms associated with its approach?
- The expansive interpretation of Article 21 by the judiciary reflects its transformative role in safeguarding not just life, but also various facets of human well-being. Elucidate this statement with the help of relevant case laws.
- Impact of digital technology as a reliable source of input for rational decision making is a debatable issue. Critically evaluate with a suitable example.
- The growth of cabinet system has practically resulted in the marginalisation of the parliamentary supremacy: Elucidate.
