GS Paper 2Cabinet system and parliamentary supremacyUPSC CSE Mains 2024

The growth of cabinet system has practically resulted in the marginalisation of the parliamentary supremacy: Elucidate.

Based on 23 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.

What most aspirants missed

  • Article 110 money bill misuse, e.g. Aadhaar Act 2016, to bypass Rajya Sabha scrutiny
  • Ordinance route under Article 123 used to bypass Parliament, e.g. the 2020 farm ordinances
  • Role of the whip and anti-defection law (10th Schedule) in making MPs vote on party lines
  • Cabinet control of the legislative agenda, session timing and prorogation, squeezing debate
  • Weakening of parliamentary committees, and government ignoring their recommendations
  • Comparison with the UK Westminster model, where cabinet dominance originated, e.g. Bagehot and Hailsham's elective dictatorship

Common mistakes

  • Listing cabinet features without explaining how each one reduces Parliament's power
  • Vague claims like 'committees are weak' without naming committees or mechanisms
  • Ignoring the Articles that empower Parliament (Articles 75(3), 107-110, 123) and the parliamentary tools that check the cabinet
  • No counterpoints, so the answer does not weigh the question or show whether marginalisation is total

What the better answers did

  • Linking the growth of the cabinet system directly to specific mechanisms such as the whip, ordinances and money bills
  • Using concrete instances such as the Aadhaar Act or the farm ordinances, with the constitutional provision cited
  • Including a counterpoint such as coalition politics or judicial review, which makes the answer balanced
  • A forward-looking conclusion with concrete suggestions, such as strengthening committees

Introduction

Open by defining parliamentary supremacy and explaining why the Westminster cabinet fuses executive and legislature, so the marginalisation argument has a clear base.

Conclusion

Close by stating whether marginalisation is total, then give two or three specific reforms, such as stronger committee referral and narrower money bill use.

Model answer

Parliamentary supremacy rests on the executive being answerable to the legislature. Walter Bagehot called the cabinet the 'efficient secret' of the British constitution because it fuses the executive and the legislature. In India, under Article 75(3), the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. The growth of cabinet dominance has indeed weakened Parliament's role, though it is not total.

How cabinet dominance marginalises Parliament

  • Collective responsibility and the anti-defection law (10th Schedule, 52nd Amendment, 1985) plus the party whip make MPs vote on party lines, reducing independent scrutiny.
  • The Cabinet controls the legislative agenda, session timing and prorogation, so debate is squeezed and Question Hour and private members' business lose time.
  • Money Bill route under Article 110: the Aadhaar Act, 2016 was certified as a money bill, limiting Rajya Sabha to recommendations and bypassing its full scrutiny.
  • Ordinance route under Article 123: the 2020 farm ordinances were promulgated before Parliament could debate them, and were later passed as Acts.
  • Delegated legislation lets the executive frame rules without debate, while Public Accounts and departmental standing committees have limited power and their recommendations are often ignored.
  • The 42nd Amendment (1976) made the advice of the Council of Ministers binding on the President under Article 74(1), centralising power further.

Limits and counterpoints

  • Article 75(3) and the no-confidence motion remain the ultimate check, and cut motions and Question Hour keep the executive accountable.
  • Coalition governments in 1989-91 and 1996-98 saw greater parliamentary leverage and committee influence.
  • The judiciary, through Kesavananda Bharati (1973) and Minerva Mills (1980), has kept both Parliament and the executive within the constitution.

Lord Hailsham's 'elective dictatorship' captures the risk: a majority-backed cabinet can dominate Parliament. Remedies include referring more bills to committees, confining money bill certification to genuinely fiscal matters, and giving committees a stronger role, so that Parliament regains its deliberative function without weakening stable government.

Write this answer and get it evaluated

Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.

Evaluate my answer

Asked in UPSC Mains 2024 GS Paper 2 (Q3). See all 2024 GS Paper 2 questions

More GS Paper 2 questions