The 103rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019 has introduced a new dimension to the principle of affirmative action in India. Critically examine its implications for the broader goal of social justice.
Based on 16 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.
What most aspirants missed
- Indra Sawhney (1992) set the 50% ceiling and treated social backwardness as the basis of reservation; the EWS quota breaches the ceiling, which must be explained
- Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India (2022): 3:2 majority upheld the amendment, with Justice Bhat's dissent on exclusion of SC/ST/OBC and the basic structure
- Exclusion of SC/ST/OBC from EWS even when economically weak, creating a parallel track that does not address cumulative disadvantage
- Income ceiling of Rs 8 lakh and land and house exclusions mirror the OBC creamy-layer test and are not linked to a validated poverty line
- Absence of systematic beneficiary data, which creates an accountability gap for social justice monitoring
- Shift from historical, caste-based discrimination to economic need, and the identity versus economic criteria debate
Common mistakes
- Describing what the amendment does without critically examining its implications for social justice
- Omitting the 50% ceiling breach and the Indra Sawhney context entirely
- Citing the Supreme Court judgment without the majority-dissent details or the reasoning
- Making vague claims (for example, about merit, women's empowerment or Gandhian ideals) without evidence or explanation
- Confusing the 103rd Amendment with the 102nd Amendment on backward class commissions
What the better answers did
- Clear structure separating positive implications from a critical examination, with a focused way forward
- Anchoring the answer in Articles 15(6) and 16(6) and the Indra Sawhney ceiling
- Using the Janhit Abhiyan case with its 3:2 split and the dissent's reasoning
- Framing the creamy-layer parallel as a sharp, specific critique of the Rs 8 lakh criterion
Introduction
Open by stating that the 103rd Amendment is the first quota based purely on economic criteria, and that this departs from the social backwardness principle in Indra Sawhney.
Conclusion
Close by linking the quota's value for social justice to whether the state fixes the SC/ST/OBC exclusion, the 50% ceiling tension and the lack of beneficiary data.
Model answer
The 103rd Amendment (2019) inserted Articles 15(6) and 16(6), enabling up to 10% reservation for Economically Weaker Sections among the unreserved categories. It is the first quota anchored purely in economic criteria, departing from the social backwardness principle that Indra Sawhney (1992) treated as the basis of reservation.
Positive implications
- Recognises that deprivation among poor forward castes is real, and gives the state a constitutional route to act on it, in line with Article 46 and the DPSPs.
- In Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India (2022), the Supreme Court upheld the amendment by a 3:2 majority, holding that it did not violate the basic structure.
- Widens the policy toolkit beyond caste categories for addressing income-based deprivation.
Critical examination
- Shifts the logic from historical, caste-based discrimination to present income. Forward castes do not face comparable social stigma, so the rationale differs from SC/ST/OBC reservation.
- Excludes SC/ST/OBC from the EWS category even when they are economically weak. Their existing quotas do not address this, so a parallel track emerges that leaves the cumulative disadvantage of these groups unaddressed.
- Along with existing quotas, total reservation rises to about 59.5%, breaching the 50% ceiling set in Indra Sawhney. Justice Bhat's dissent in Janhit Abhiyan argued that the exclusion of SC/ST/OBC undermines equality and the basic structure.
- The Rs 8 lakh income ceiling and the land and house exclusions mirror the OBC creamy-layer test. This is arbitrary for a group defined by economic, not social, criteria, and it is not linked to a validated poverty line.
- There is no systematic data on EWS beneficiaries, which makes it hard to verify whether benefits reach the intended poor.
Way forward
- Mandate collection of beneficiary data by category, income and region, and review the income ceiling periodically against a credible poverty measure.
- Support poor SC/ST/OBC candidates through existing schemes rather than parallel quotas, and invest in school education and skilling, which address the root cause.
The amendment expands the idea of affirmative action but risks weakening its social justice core. Its value depends on whether the state corrects the exclusions, the 50% ceiling tension and the monitoring gap.
Write this answer and get it evaluated
Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.
Evaluate my answerMore GS Paper 2 questions
- What constitutes corrupt practices under the Representation of the People Act, 1951? Also, discuss the challenges in curbing such malpractices and suggest remedial measures.
- Discuss the role of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in the development of developing countries. What are the key criticisms associated with its approach?
- The expansive interpretation of Article 21 by the judiciary reflects its transformative role in safeguarding not just life, but also various facets of human well-being. Elucidate this statement with the help of relevant case laws.
- Impact of digital technology as a reliable source of input for rational decision making is a debatable issue. Critically evaluate with a suitable example.
- The growth of cabinet system has practically resulted in the marginalisation of the parliamentary supremacy: Elucidate.
- The District Planning Committee (DPC) was envisioned as a key instrument to strengthen grassroots-level planning. How far has it succeeded in achieving this goal? Discuss the challenges faced by DPCs and suggest measures to make them more effective.
