GS Paper 2GST and fiscal federalismUPSC CSE Mains 2023

Explain the significance of the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act. To what extent does it reflect the accommodative spirit of federalism?

Based on 22 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.

What most aspirants missed

  • Article 246A: concurrent power of Parliament and state legislatures to levy GST, the core constitutional change of the amendment
  • Article 269A and IGST: how inter-state supply revenue is collected by the Centre and apportioned to states
  • GST Council voting: Centre holds one-third, states two-thirds, with a three-fourths majority needed for decisions
  • Exclusions such as petroleum, alcohol for human consumption and electricity, which preserve state revenue autonomy
  • Mohit Minerals (2022): Council recommendations are persuasive, not binding, which frames the limits of accommodation

Common mistakes

  • Describing the amendment only as 'One Nation One Tax' without naming the constitutional articles or the Council structure
  • Stating 'to what extent' without giving a verdict, or treating cooperative and accommodative federalism as the same thing without explaining the difference
  • Quoting outdated or wrong facts, such as GST rate slabs or the compensation cess end date
  • Vague claims like 'improved tax collections' or 'boosted economy' without any figure or mechanism

What the better answers did

  • Linking each feature (Articles 246A, 269A, 279A) to a specific federal principle such as shared sovereignty or state voice
  • Using the compensation guarantee and exclusions to show accommodation, and the Mohit Minerals ruling and compensation delays to show limits
  • Ending with a clear, balanced verdict that answers the 'to what extent' part

Introduction

Open by naming the 101st Amendment, the three key articles, and the dual GST model, then state that the answer will weigh accommodation against fiscal limits.

Conclusion

Give a clear verdict that the design is largely accommodative but fiscal autonomy concerns remain, and tie it to the test of how the consensus model handles revenue stress.

Model answer

The 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016 created a single indirect tax, the Goods and Services Tax (GST), replacing a maze of central and state levies. It inserted Article 246A, giving Parliament and state legislatures concurrent power to make GST laws, Article 269A for inter-state supplies (IGST), and Article 279A for the GST Council as a constitutional body. Its federal character lies in combining a unified market with shared decision-making.

Significance

  • Removed tax barriers between states and created one common national market, subsuming central levies such as excise duty and service tax and state levies such as VAT, entry tax and octroi.
  • Article 279A made the GST Council a constitutional body in which the Union holds one-third and states two-thirds of weighted votes, with decisions needing a three-fourths majority.
  • Under Article 269A, IGST is collected by the Centre and apportioned to states, and destination-based taxation shifts revenue to consuming states.

Accommodative features

  • Dual GST: CGST and SGST let states levy tax on intra-state supplies and set SGST rates within the Council framework.
  • Compensation: states were guaranteed 14 per cent annual growth over the 2015-16 base for five years under the GST (Compensation to States) Act, 2017, funded by a compensation cess that stopped collection in June 2022.
  • Petroleum, alcohol for human consumption and electricity stay outside GST, keeping important revenue sources with states.
  • Article 279A(9) provides a dispute resolution mechanism, and the Kerala Flood Cess (2018) shows room for state-specific provisions.

Limits

  • States surrendered their power to tax goods and services, and Council recommendations are persuasive rather than binding, as the Supreme Court held in the Mohit Minerals case (2022).
  • Delays in compensation during the COVID period, and the Centre's offer to borrow instead of paying directly, exposed the asymmetry in fiscal dependence.

On balance, the amendment is largely accommodative in design, with an equal state voice in the Council and guaranteed revenue protection, but fiscal autonomy concerns remain. Its real test is whether the consensus model holds under revenue stress. Seen this way, GST is cooperative federalism in practice, though the Centre's leverage over compensation keeps the balance uneven.

Write this answer and get it evaluated

Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.

Evaluate my answer

Asked in UPSC Mains 2023 GS Paper 2 (Q15). See all 2023 GS Paper 2 questions

More GS Paper 2 questions