GS Paper 1Urbanisation and women's statusUPSC CSE Mains 2024

Globalization has increased urban migration by skilled, young, unmarried women from various classes. How has this trend impacted upon their personal freedom and relationship with family?

Based on 22 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.

What most aspirants missed

  • Remittances shifting power within the family, as in the Kerala Gulf migration pattern, with women sending money home and renegotiating family roles
  • Class variation: middle-class women in white-collar IT/BPO jobs versus working-class women in domestic work, retail and garments
  • Digital communication (video calls, family WhatsApp groups) sustaining family ties and changing forms of surveillance
  • Safety and harassment concerns, citing NCRB data and the POSH Act 2013, as limits on the freedom to move and work
  • Delayed marriage and live-in relationships as direct markers of personal freedom, with the Khushboo case (2010) as legal backing

Common mistakes

  • Treating all migrant women as one homogeneous group and ignoring the question's explicit reference to various classes
  • Listing only positives or only negatives, when the question asks how the trend has impacted freedom and family relations
  • Offering claims without examples, data or cases, so the answer reads as generic opinion
  • Using stereotypical or unverifiable framing, such as blaming western values for loss of respect to elders, instead of analysing generational value conflicts

What the better answers did

  • Linking globalisation to specific job sectors (IT, BPO, healthcare) and to urban migration, rather than writing a general essay on women's empowerment
  • Showing both expansion and negotiation of freedom, such as delayed marriage alongside continued marriage preference
  • Using concrete legal and data anchors like the Khushboo judgment, NFHS/Census trends and NCRB records
  • Analysing family relations through remittances, communication patterns and changing household structures

Introduction

Open by linking globalisation-driven job growth in metros to the shift in women's residence and autonomy, and signal that the impact is uneven across classes.

Conclusion

Close by stating that freedom is negotiated within families rather than granted, and name one institutional need such as safe housing or workplace safety enforcement.

Model answer

Globalisation has widened job markets in IT, BPO, banking, healthcare and retail, drawing young women to metros and Tier-2 cities. Migration loosens direct supervision by family and community, but it also brings new pressures. The impact on freedom and family ties is uneven and varies by class.

Expansion of personal freedom

  • Financial independence enables choices on career, residence and lifestyle. Many women working in Bengaluru and Hyderabad live in women-only PGs, a shift from family-controlled residence.
  • Delayed marriage: rising age at marriage, seen in NFHS and Census trends, reflects priority to education and careers, though marriage remains the dominant expectation.
  • The Supreme Court in Khushboo v. Kanniammal (2010) observed that live-in relationships are not illegal, giving legal space to partner choice outside sacramental marriage.

Changing family relations

  • Remittances shift bargaining power. A earning daughter's money can influence decisions on siblings' education and household expenses, though families may still press women to send money.
  • Video calls and family messaging groups sustain ties across distance, but they also make communication and monitoring constant.
  • Nuclear households are rising and joint family norms weaken. Generational conflicts over marriage, dress and mobility emerge, and many families negotiate rather than reject the daughter's choices.

Constraints on freedom

  • Workplace harassment and unsafe commutes limit mobility. NCRB data show persistently high crimes against women, and the POSH Act 2013 is unevenly enforced in smaller firms.
  • Loneliness in cities and the double burden of career and family expectations strain mental health and work-life balance.
  • Class divide: skilled professionals in IT and BPO have more autonomy than working-class women in domestic work or retail, who often live in shared, insecure housing and send most earnings home.

Urban migration expands personal freedom mainly for educated women, but this freedom is negotiated rather than granted. Family ties are being redefined through money and technology rather than simply weakened. Lasting empowerment needs safe cities, affordable women's hostels and support for women carrying dual responsibilities.

Write this answer and get it evaluated

Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.

Evaluate my answer

Asked in UPSC Mains 2024 GS Paper 1 (Q19). See all 2024 GS Paper 1 questions

More GS Paper 1 questions