How far was the Industrial Revolution in England responsible for the decline of handicrafts and cottage industries in India?
Based on 28 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.
What most aspirants missed
- Dhaka muslin's collapse as a concrete example: machine-made cloth undercut it and weavers' incomes fell sharply in Bengal.
- Calico Acts of 1720 and 1721 as early discriminatory measures that protected British weavers against Indian cloth.
- Quantified deindustrialisation: India's share of world manufacturing fell from roughly a quarter in 1750 to a few percent by 1900.
- Tariff asymmetry: Indian exports faced heavy duties in Britain while British cloth entered India at low or no duty after 1813.
- Drain of Wealth (Dadabhai Naoroji) linking raw material exports and finished goods imports to capital flight and no reinvestment.
- A direct 'how far' verdict that separates the Industrial Revolution's role from colonial policy and indigenous factors.
Common mistakes
- Listing features of the Industrial Revolution without linking each one to the decline of a specific Indian craft.
- Giving no data, so the answer cannot show the extent of decline; a single export or share figure would strengthen it.
- Presenting colonial policy and indigenous factors as a list without judging their relative weight in the 'how far' demand.
- Mixing in later events, such as Quit India or unrelated wars, that have no bearing on the decline of handicrafts.
What the better answers did
- Tying each point to a named craft or region, such as Dhaka muslin, Surat textiles or Bengal weavers.
- Explaining the mechanism: power looms and tariffs made Indian goods uncompetitive in both home and export markets.
- Giving a clear verdict on 'how far' and stating which factors were primary and which secondary.
- Using Naoroji's Drain of Wealth and the shift from exporter to importer of textiles to connect economics to colonial policy.
Introduction
Define the Industrial Revolution's timeframe and its textile shift in one line, then state that the answer will judge its role relative to colonial policy.
Conclusion
End with a clear verdict: the Industrial Revolution was a major cause of decline in cotton, working through colonial trade policy, with indigenous factors shaping regional outcomes.
Model answer
The Industrial Revolution in England (roughly 1760 to 1840) moved cloth production from hand to power-driven factories. Its impact on Indian handicrafts was severe, especially in cotton, but it worked through colonial trade policy. It was a decisive external cause, though not the only one.
Direct competition from machine-made goods
- Power looms and spinning machines cut British cloth prices sharply, and Manchester goods undercut Dhaka muslin and coarse Indian cloth.
- After the Charter Act of 1813 ended the Company's trade monopoly and opened India to private British traders, imports of machine-made cloth rose steeply.
Colonial policy that amplified the shock
- The Calico Acts (1720 and 1721) had already restricted Indian printed cotton in Britain, showing the priority given to British producers.
- Tariffs were lopsided: British cloth entered India at low duties, while Indian goods faced heavy duties in the British market.
- India was pushed to export raw cotton and import finished cloth. Naoroji's Drain of Wealth argument shows that the surplus left the country and was not reinvested locally.
Indigenous and other factors
- The decline of Mughal and regional courts removed patronage for luxury crafts such as Banarasi silk and Dhaka muslin.
- Rigid guild and caste structures limited innovation, and artisans often lacked capital to adopt new techniques.
Assessing the extent
- Industrial competition and colonial policy together account for most of the decline in cotton. Bengal was hit harder than western regions.
- Some artisans moved into jute mills, railway work and agricultural labour, while Swadeshi efforts later tried to revive crafts.
English industrialisation was therefore a major cause of decline, operating mainly through colonial trade policy. Indigenous weaknesses shaped regional outcomes. Its responsibility is large for cotton textiles, but only partial for the wider handicraft economy.
Write this answer and get it evaluated
Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.
Evaluate my answerAsked in UPSC Mains 2024 GS Paper 1 (Q13). See all 2024 GS Paper 1 questions
More GS Paper 1 questions
- Examine the role of 'Gig Economy' in the process of empowerment of women in India.
- Explain the role of geographical factors towards the development of Ancient India.
- Folk music serves as a repository of the cultural identity. Discuss the role of folk music in preserving cultural heritage and promoting social cohesion.
- Discuss the possible factors that inhibit India from enacting for its citizens a uniform civil code as provided for in the Directive Principles of State Policy.
- What factors affect the formation of a person's attitude towards social problems? In our society, contrasting attitudes are prevalent about many social problems. What contrasting attitudes do you notice about the caste system in our society? How do you explain the existence of these contrasting attitudes?
- Globalization has increased urban migration by skilled, young, unmarried women from various classes. How has this trend impacted upon their personal freedom and relationship with family?
