Supreme Court cases UPSC keeps coming back to, with what each one held.
Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution, Fundamental Rights included; an amendment is not 'law' under Art. 13.
Reversed Shankari Prasad: Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights. Answered by the 24th Amendment (1971).
Parliament can amend any part, but not the basic structure. The Preamble is part of the Constitution. Overruled Golaknath.
Struck down the 39th Amendment clause that put the PM's election beyond courts; free and fair elections are basic structure.
Struck down 42nd Amendment clauses giving Parliament unlimited amending power and DPSPs primacy over all FRs. Limited amending power and the FR-DPSP balance are basic structure.
Ninth Schedule laws added after 24 April 1973 can be tested against the basic structure.
Laws put in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 are open to judicial review if they violate the basic structure.
Struck down the NJAC and the 99th Amendment; judicial independence is basic structure. The collegium continues.
Read Art. 21 narrowly: any procedure laid down by law was enough. Rejected by R.C. Cooper (1970) and Maneka Gandhi (1978).
Procedure under Art. 21 must be just, fair and reasonable; Art. 14, 19 and 21 are linked (the golden triangle). Arose from the impounding of her passport.
Upheld 27% OBC reservation; excluded the creamy layer; capped reservation at 50% save in extraordinary cases; no reservation in promotions (later restored by the 77th Amendment).
Upheld reservation in promotion, subject to data on backwardness, inadequate representation and efficiency. Jarnail Singh (2018) dropped the backwardness data requirement for SC/ST.
Upheld 10% EWS reservation (103rd Amendment) by 3:2.
By 6:1, states may sub-classify SCs and STs for reservation; overruled E.V. Chinnaiah (2004).
Privacy is a Fundamental Right under Art. 21. Aadhaar was upheld with limits in 2018.
Decriminalised consensual same-sex relations by reading down Section 377 IPC.
Struck down adultery (Section 497 IPC) as violating Art. 14, 15 and 21.
Instant triple talaq (talaq-e-biddat) is unconstitutional.
Women of all ages may enter the Sabarimala temple; the issue was later referred to a larger bench.
Struck down Section 66A of the IT Act for being vague and chilling free speech.
Internet shutdowns must be proportionate, temporary and open to review; speech and trade over the internet are protected by Art. 19.
Laid down guidelines against sexual harassment at the workplace; replaced by the POSH Act, 2013.
Right to livelihood is part of the right to life.
Right to education up to 14 flows from Art. 21; led to Art. 21A.
Right to die with dignity; passive euthanasia and living wills allowed. Aruna Shanbaug (2011) first allowed passive euthanasia.
Recognised transgender persons as a third gender with full Fundamental Rights.
No fundamental right to marry; recognising same-sex marriage is for Parliament.
Struck down the electoral bonds scheme for violating voters' right to information.
Speedy trial is part of Art. 21; an early PIL that led to the release of thousands of undertrials.
Guidelines on arrest and detention to prevent custodial violence.
President's Rule is open to judicial review; majority must be tested on the floor of the House. Secularism is basic structure.
Dissolution of the Bihar assembly in 2005 was unconstitutional; the Governor's report was mala fide.
Governor cannot advance an assembly session on his own; Arunachal government restored.
Governors serve at the President's pleasure but cannot be removed arbitrarily or for political reasons.
Upheld the Tenth Schedule; the Speaker's decision on defection is open to judicial review.
The Lieutenant Governor is bound by the Delhi cabinet's aid and advice except on police, public order and land; services are with the elected government (2023).
Upheld the abrogation of Article 370; J&K had no internal sovereignty. Directed elections and early restoration of statehood.
Repeated re-promulgation of ordinances is a fraud on the Constitution.
Legislators get no immunity under Art. 105 or 194 for taking bribes to vote or speak; overruled P.V. Narasimha Rao (1998).
Set timelines for Governors to act on bills and declared 10 Tamil Nadu bills deemed assented.
Advisory opinion: courts cannot impose timelines on the Governor or President and there is no deemed assent; but prolonged, unexplained inaction can be examined by courts.
Executive primacy in judicial appointments; widened locus standi for PIL.
Created the collegium: primacy of the CJI and senior judges.
Collegium expanded to the CJI and four senior-most judges.
Seven directives on police reform: fixed tenure, State Security Commission, separating investigation from law and order.
Statutory status for the CVC and safeguards for CBI independence.
Legislators convicted with two or more years' sentence are disqualified at once; struck down Section 8(4) of the RPA.
Candidates must disclose criminal record, assets and education.
Introduced NOTA on voting machines.
Election Commissioners to be chosen by the PM, Leader of Opposition and CJI until Parliament makes a law (Parliament then passed the 2023 Act).
Fixed tenure for civil servants and civil services boards; written orders, not oral.
Absolute liability for hazardous industries, stricter than strict liability.
Adopted the precautionary principle and polluter pays as part of Indian law.
'Forest' means any area in the dictionary sense, regardless of ownership.
Public trust doctrine: the State holds natural resources in trust for the public.
Gram sabhas decide whether mining affects their religious and cultural rights under the Forest Rights Act.
Right against the adverse effects of climate change is part of Art. 14 and 21.