You are the Director of the National Bioethics Commission who is responsible for assessing the ethical feasibility and oversight of a nationwide genome sequencing program. The project named GeneFuture, aims to sequence the DNA of every newborn child and store it in a centralized national database. The objective is to identify genetic predispositions to serious diseases early in life, allowing for preventive treatment and personalized medicine. Over 100,000 babies have already been enrolled in the pilot phase of the program. The government claims that this move is a landmark step in public health advancement. However, collection of newborn genetic data raises significant ethical concerns, particularly around informed consent, which may not fully capture parents’ understanding of the long-term risks involved. Once gathered, this sensitive data could be misused for purposes such as surveillance, insurance discrimination, or commercial marketing by third parties. Uncertainty over data ownership, whether it lies with the state, parents, or the individual child’s future, further complicates the issue. The involvement of private tech and pharmaceutical companies heightens fears of commercial exploitation, especially in the absence of clear mechanisms for individuals to withdraw consent or delete their genetic information upon reaching adulthood. (a) What are the ethical issues you perceive in the implementation of the GeneFuture program? (b) Identify the conflicting interests of different stakeholders in this case. (c) What guiding ethical principles would you recommend for implementation of this project?
Based on 17 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.
What most aspirants missed
- Children cannot consent at birth, and the right to genetic self-determination at adulthood is rarely addressed.
- A sunset clause that deletes data at 18 unless the individual re-consents, which directly tackles withdrawal.
- Specific legal safeguards such as GINA in the US, and the DPDP Act, 2023 in India, against genetic discrimination in insurance and employment.
- International precedents: Iceland's deCODE controversy and the UK Biobank opt-in consent model.
- Data security protocols, encryption and breach notification as ethical requirements.
- An independent ethics committee with diverse representation and specific oversight of private company access.
Common mistakes
- Listing many issues without linking them to bioethics principles such as autonomy, non-maleficence and justice.
- Naming Puttaswamy or trusteeship without applying them to the case.
- Vague stakeholder analysis that omits children, future generations and insurers.
- Proposing a fresh pilot even though 100,000 babies are already enrolted, which shows the answer ignored the case facts.
- Overlong ethics lists that repeat consent and commercial exploitation points.
What the better answers did
- Linking each ethical issue to a named principle such as autonomy or non-maleficence.
- Giving concrete stakeholder clashes, for example parents seeking prevention versus fearing discrimination.
- Recommending specific safeguards: a sunset clause, GINA-style law, encryption, an independent ethics committee.
- Ending with a clear recommendation for the existing pilot cohort, such as audit and re-consent.
Introduction
Open by noting that the newborn cannot consent and that the data is lifelong, which frames the whole answer around autonomy and future harm.
Conclusion
Close by recommending an audit and re-consent of the 100,000 enrolled babies, with a sunset clause, so public health gains do not override the child's future autonomy.
Model answer
GeneFuture offers early detection and personalised medicine, but sequencing every newborn raises serious ethical questions. The child cannot consent, the data is permanent, and misuse can harm the child for life. The answer below sets out the issues, stakeholder conflicts and guiding principles.
(a) Ethical issues
- Informed consent: Parents consent on the child's behalf and may not grasp long-term risks. This weakens the principle of autonomy.
- Genetic privacy: Privacy is protected under Article 21 (Puttaswamy, 2017). Surveillance or sale of genetic data breaches it.
- Discrimination: Insurance premium hikes, employment bias and social stigma are real risks. Without legal safeguards, non-maleficence is violated.
- Future autonomy: The adult may not want to know or be tested. The right to genetic self-determination needs a working mechanism.
- Ownership and security: It is unclear whether the state, parents or the child owns the data. Hacking and foreign access threaten data sovereignty.
(b) Conflicting interests
- Parents want disease prevention but fear future discrimination against their child.
- The government seeks public health gains, while citizens seek privacy and trust.
- Pharma and tech firms seek commercial returns, which clash with public trust and the child's interests.
- Insurers want risk-based premiums, which conflicts with the newborn's right to fair cover.
- Researchers want large datasets, while future adults want control over their own data.
(c) Guiding principles
- Autonomy: Re-consent at 18, with a sunset clause that deletes data unless the adult opts in.
- Non-maleficence: Encryption, access controls, breach notification and a GINA-style anti-discrimination law, alongside the DPDP Act, 2023.
- Justice and beneficence: Equitable access to benefits and benefit-sharing with marginalised communities.
- Transparency and accountability: An independent ethics committee with diverse representation, IRB-style review of private access, and genetic counselling for families.
GeneFuture should be paused for an audit and re-consent of the 100,000 enrolled babies, anchored in the UNESCO Declaration on Human Genetic Data and lessons from deCODE and UK Biobank. Public health gains are valid only if the child's future autonomy is protected.
Write this answer and get it evaluated
Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.
Evaluate my answerMore GS Paper 4 (Ethics) questions
- Online methodology is being used for day-to-day meetings, institutional approvals in the administration and for teaching and learning in education sector to the extent telemedicine in the health sector is getting popular with the approvals of the competent authority. No doubt, it has advantages and disadvantages for both the beneficiaries and the system at large. Describe and discuss the ethical issues involved in the use of online method particularly to the vulnerable section of the society.
- You are posted as the Joint Secretary in the Department of Information Technology of a state. The government recently implemented several citizen-centric digital services, collecting large values of personal data from residents. The Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, requires that such data be processed only with explicit and informed consent, and mandates that processing must cease immediately upon withdrawal of consent. During an internal audit, you discover that the department continues to process and analyze personal data of several citizens even after they have formally withdrawn their consent. This data is being used for policy analytics and service improvement, purposes not explicitly disclosed at the time of data collection. When you bring this to the attention of your department head, you are informed that halting the processing will disrupt ongoing digital initiatives and may affect state-level performance metrics. Moreover, you find that the consent withdrawal process is cumbersome, and many citizens are unaware of their rights under the DPDP Act. At this point, you learn that a prominent social activist is planning to file a complaint with the Data Protection Board against involuntary use of personal data, which could attract public scrutiny and legal action against the department. (a) Identify and discuss the ethical issues involved in this case. (b) What are the potential consequences for the department if the issue is not addressed transparently? (c) How would you balance the need for efficient public service delivery with the obligation to protect citizens' data rights?
- In public service, emotional intelligence is not about suppressing emotion, but mastering its purpose to connect, to de-escalate, and to uplift others with empathy and strength. Do you agree with this view? Discuss.
- You are the Secretary in the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT), Government of India. In recent years, an increasing number of civil servants, particularly younger officers from the IAS, IPS, and IRS, have begun maintaining personal YouTube channels and social media pages. On these platforms, they regularly post videos related to their official work, showcasing innovative projects, public outreach initiatives, inspection drives, and sometimes even day-to-day administrative duties. These videos often receive widespread public attention, and many viewers express admiration, saying such content enhances transparency, motivates aspirants, and humanizes the bureaucracy. However, some criticism has emerged from various quarters. Some officers' share of personal content may blur the boundaries between personal branding and public service, while some citizens and media commentators point to instances where official premises are used for unauthorized shoots without consent, may incur the risk of misuse of official premises, or are designed more for personal popularity than public accountability. In one case, a district magistrate was seen filming a surprise school inspection in which teachers were scolded on camera. The video was later posted to his personal YouTube channel, which is also monetized. While some parents admired the officer's strictness, others criticized the public shaming of teachers and said it breached service dignity. In another case, a police officer in a motivation video during a flood rescue operation, in which staff filmed footage later edited into a motivational dance reel, received appreciation but was asked to show that proper footage permission had been obtained and that official limitations were observed. These instances have stirred a debate in civil services circles. On one side are the official, the institution involved, and wider civil servants publicly showcasing their official work on social media. (a) Identify the ethical issues involved in civil servants publicly showcasing their official work on social media. (b) Does such content promote awareness and motivation, or does it compromise the values of anonymity, neutrality, and collective service ethos? Give your opinion. (c) As the Secretary, what guiding principles and policy recommendations would you suggest to ensure responsible social media engagement by civil servants?
- You are an IAS officer, currently serving as the Secretary of the Public Works Department in a hill state. Recently, a disturbing incident has come to light involving a senior Cabinet Minister and some engineers of the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI). During an inspection of a critical highway project, the Minister was allegedly seen on video physically assaulting and verbally abusing the engineers in full public view. The video recorded by bystanders, went viral on social media and was widely covered by the television channels, sparking both outrage and support from different sections of society. The Minister later defended his actions, alleging that the officials were corrupt, unresponsive to local grievances, and purposely unmotivated, which delayed the project itself. He insisted his response was driven by public frustration against delays in delivering infrastructure to the remote region. However, the engineers have filed a police complaint and written to their superiors, claiming they were targeted for resisting political pressures to allow NHAI contractors to sidestep laid down norms and timelines. As the situation escalated, a union of NHAI engineers declared a strike, demanding action against the Minister and protection of officer dignity. This has brought several critical infrastructure projects to a standstill, including road connectivity to tribal areas, pre-monsoon repair works, and strategic border roads. You have been directed by the Chief Secretary to prepare a fact-finding report, while also ensuring smooth administration between state and central agencies. Meanwhile, the Minister's spokespersons are presenting you to the Government and public as the official who stands at the serious periphery of the Minister as a crusader against corruption, others considering this act as a serious breach of coordination ethics and rule of law. Civil servants and Minister's office are both encouraging private resolution, but failed infrastructural work means public and citizens are now growing restless due to halted infrastructure works. (a) Who are the major stakeholders, and what actions will you take to resolve the issue while balancing the conflicting interests of the stakeholders and restoring the dignity of officials? (b) As the Secretary of the PWD, what actions will you take in the above situation? (c) What are the possible lessons that the morale of civil servants and public trust in governance?
- It is believed that adherence to ethics in human actions would ensure in smooth functioning of an organization/system. If so, what does ethics seek to promote in human life? How do ethical values assist in the resolution of conflicts faced by him in his day-to-day functioning?
