GS Paper 4 (Ethics)Ethics of changing marriage

Marriages in India are transitioning from traditional sacramental unions to more autonomous relationships, reflected in live-in relationships and rising divorce rates. Discuss the ethical dimensions of these changes

Based on 17 evaluated answers to this question on CollectorBabu: here is what aspirants most often missed, the mistakes that cost marks, and a model answer.

What most aspirants missed

  • Gender justice as a positive ethical dimension, including how women's agency differs from men's, with Indra Sarma as an example
  • Legal-ethical tension: Supreme Court recognition of live-in relationships (Indra Sarma, 2013) versus social norms
  • Impact on children's rights and wellbeing, and value transmission when family structures change
  • Elderly care crisis as an ethical duty issue, not only a practical one
  • Clear use of at least one framework (deontology, utilitarianism or virtue ethics) to weigh the changes
  • Positive and negative ethical dimensions placed in a balanced discussion

Common mistakes

  • Listing implications without analysing the ethical tensions between autonomy and family or social stability
  • Bare assertions without examples, such as claims about women's empowerment or moral decline
  • Judgmental language, such as 'corrupts minds' or 'pleasure without conscience', instead of ethical analysis
  • Incorrect or unverified statistics, such as overstating divorce rates

What the better answers did

  • Balanced structure that sets out ethical gains and costs separately, then reconciles them
  • Specific legal references such as Indra Sarma, Puttaswamy and the Domestic Violence Act, 2005
  • Use of named ethical frameworks to test the changes, with a short explanation of each
  • A conclusion that proposes a practical ethical balance, such as legal safeguards and care systems

Introduction

Open by framing the core dilemma as autonomy versus duty to family and children, rather than simply describing the trends.

Conclusion

Close by naming the specific safeguards (consent, economic security for women, elderly care) that protect the ethical balance.

Model answer

Changing marriage patterns in India pose a core ethical question: should individual autonomy and well-being take precedence over duties to family, children and tradition? Live-in relationships and rising separations test both the institution of marriage and the values it sustains.

Ethical gains

  • Autonomy and consent: free choice of partner is affirmed under the right to privacy (Puttaswamy, 2017) and Article 21.
  • Gender justice: women can exit abusive unions. Indra Sarma v. V.K.V. Sarma (2013) held live-in relationships not illegal and extended Domestic Violence Act protection to a 'relationship in the nature of marriage'.
  • Utilitarian gain: adults trapped in unhappy unions gain well-being when they can separate. NFHS-5 shows divorce remains below 2 per cent of ever-married women, so the change is gradual, not an upheaval.

Ethical costs

  • Children: parents owe a duty of stability and value transmission. Indra Sarma held children of such unions not illegitimate, yet maintenance and custody gaps remain.
  • Elderly: as joint-family support weakens, care obligations shift to the state, raising care-ethics concerns (Gilligan).
  • Autonomy vs community: Mill's harm principle justifies personal choice unless it harms others. The line is contested when children or elders bear the cost.
  • Economic vulnerability: after separation, women may face dependence. Autonomy without economic security is limited.

Reconciling frameworks

  • Deontology stresses promise-keeping and duties; consequentialism weighs outcomes for individuals and children.
  • Virtue ethics asks for commitment and responsibility within freedom.
  • Religious ethics treats marriage as a sacrament, while secular ethics treats it as a consensual contract. The Special Marriage Act, 1954 offers a neutral route.

Conclusion: the ethical task is not to choose between tradition and autonomy but to protect consent, gender justice, and the welfare of children and elders while the institution adapts. Legal safeguards, economic security for women and care support for the elderly form the practical middle path.

Write this answer and get it evaluated

Handwritten answers, expert-reviewed, back in under 24 hours. Start UPSC Mains answer evaluation with the ₹49 Trial.

Evaluate my answer

More GS Paper 4 (Ethics) questions