UPSC CSE 2023 interview, Raj Shukla board
How the board approached it
The board moved from macroeconomics and debt into a long run of geopolitics, then tax and GST, then social issues like women's rights and dowry, and ended with CAA and RCTs. It questioned in rapid sequence, frequently challenging the candidate's stated opinions with counter-questions, and pressed hard on factual details like GDP and GST Council voting rules.
ChairChairman
- 1
Where are you from, what is your graduation subject, and where did you graduate from?
Background - 2
Many countries' debt is rising. As an economist, what is your opinion on this?
Economics: Public debt - ↳
So you are saying developing countries should not be concerned about debt?
Follow-upEconomics: Public debt - ↳
What about developed nations, such as the US and its debt?
Follow-upEconomics: US debt - ↳
The US has very high debt yet does not seem concerned. Why do you think that is?
Follow-upEconomics: US debt - 3
Do you also think the US military plays a major role in its being a great economy?
US military and economy - ↳
Is it military power that makes the US economically strong, given it forced Saudi Arabia to sell oil in exchange for military protection?
Follow-upUS military and economyCandidate: Disagreed with that view and gave Russia as an example instead.
- ↳
Russia has a reckless military policy and a weak economy. Why does it not care, and does it not fear economic consequences of its military actions?
Follow-upRussia - 4
What is the GDP of Russia?
Russia: Economy - 5
What is your opinion on Iran? Why is it violating basic principles of economics?
Iran - ↳
How does Iran dare to violate US sanctions and still fund its proxies?
Follow-upIran: Sanctions - 6
What is Iran's aim in funding Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis?
Iran: Proxies - 7
Recent attacks in the Red Sea region, and China's aggressive military posture toward India, are concerns. Is India's defence allocation enough to deal with this?
Defence budgetCandidate: Said the defence budget is increasing; the chairman disagreed.
- ↳
How should India deal with these threats, and what should it do in terms of economics?
Follow-upNational security economics - 8
Can technology substitute manpower in the military?
Defence technologyCandidate: The chairman agreed and cited Ukraine as an example.
M1Member 1
- 9
What should be the ideal share of direct and indirect taxes in tax revenue?
Taxation: Direct vs indirect - ↳
So should direct taxes be higher than indirect taxes, or the reverse? Why?
Follow-upTaxation: Direct vs indirect - 10
There is a demand to abolish income tax. What is your opinion?
Income tax - 11
Are we not burdening corporates with both corporate tax and capital gains tax? Are they duplicates, and is there a cascading effect?
Corporate tax and capital gains
M2Member 2
- 12
Should capital gains tax be abolished? How do you justify your stand?
Capital gains taxCandidate: Said no to abolition, with reasons.
- 13
Does GST violate the federal structure of India by taking away the rights of states?
GST and federalism - ↳
In the US, states have separate tax laws and taxing powers, while India has an integrated tax. Why, and which fiscal federalism is stronger?
Follow-upFiscal federalism - 14
What is the share of states in the GST Council?
GST Council - 15
Has any GST Council resolution been passed that required a vote?
GST Council - 16
What is the Union's share in the GST Council, and what majority is needed to pass a decision?
GST Council - 17
What reforms would you suggest for the GST Council?
GST Council reformsCandidate: Suggested consensus.
- ↳
Consensus cannot be law. How will you enforce it?
Follow-upGST Council reforms - 18
What is the current employment situation in the country?
Employment - ↳
Why is there unemployment even though we are growing very fast?
Follow-upEmployment and growth - 19
How do you impart skills?
Skilling - ↳
Despite several skilling initiatives, skills are not improving and the gap is not closing. Why?
Follow-upSkilling - ↳
Why is it taking so long?
Follow-upSkilling - 20
Why are you interested in writing about women's rights?
Women rights - ↳
How will blogging change family thinking, when society is essentially a collection of families?
Follow-upWomen rights: Social change - 21
What do you write about?
Writing and blogging - 22
Many cybercrimes occur in the country. Why are police unable to prevent them?
Cybercrime - ↳
Why are these crimes happening? Is our cybercrime law not strong enough?
Follow-upCybercrime law - 23
Agriculture is vital to India, so the government introduced farm laws, which led to protests. Why did the protests happen?
Farm laws - 24
Why are middlemen so powerful in India, especially in rural markets?
Agricultural marketsCandidate: Agreed that this is a sad state of affairs in agriculture.
- 25
Despite high literacy rates, dowry persists, especially in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. Why?
Dowry - ↳
How can the dowry culture be changed?
Follow-upDowry
M3Member 3
- 26
How can the budget be used to empower women? What interventions are needed in the budget?
Gender budgeting - 27
Is gender budgeting derived from the budget, or is it compiled before the budget?
Gender budgeting - 28
What are the components of gender budgeting?
Gender budgetingCandidate: Said not aware; asked to guess.
- ↳
Is gender budgeting done in all areas? Where do we need to intervene?
Follow-upGender budgeting - ↳
If you are constructing a road and a bridge, can this be part of gender budgeting?
Follow-upGender budgeting - 29
What schemes has the government introduced specifically for women under Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan?
Women-specific schemes - 30
You wrote this magazine in college. How did COVID-19 affect your ability to write it?
Magazine and COVID - 31
How was your master's course affected by COVID?
Master's course and COVID - 32
Can you recall the constitutional articles relating to allocation of business? How does the government allocate business?
Constitution: Allocation of business - 33
Shootings happen in the US almost every other day. Why?
US gun violence - ↳
Why are US gun laws a problem, and what is their significance?
Follow-upUS gun laws
M4Member 4
- 34
Apart from biryani, what else is there in Hyderabadi cuisine?
Hyderabad - 35
Why did the CAA lead to protests? What was the driving force behind them?
CAA - ↳
Does the CAA take away the rights of Indian Muslims?
Follow-upCAA - ↳
What are the concerns with this law?
Follow-upCAA - 36
What about the NRC?
NRC - 37
What is the latest development in economics you can tell me about?
Economics: Recent developmentsCandidate: Talked about randomised controlled trials (RCTs).
- ↳
How can RCTs be used? What is Abhijit Banerjee's theory?
Follow-upEconomics: RCTs - ↳
Give an example of how this worked on the ground, if you know of one.
Follow-upEconomics: RCTs - ↳
Gossip and word of mouth are a better way of spreading news. That is not new, is it?
Follow-upCommunication and newsCandidate: Agreed.
- 38
The Saudi riyal and the dollar exchange rate is always constant. Why? Is there an agreement behind it?
Saudi currency and dollar
What to take from this interview
- ✓Expect the board to push back on your opinions with counter-questions, so defend your view with specific evidence and be ready to revise it if the counter is valid.
- ✓Prepare factual basics for your optional and current affairs, such as Russia's GDP, GST Council composition and voting thresholds, and the gender budget components.
- ✓Connect your DAF interests, like women's rights and your magazine work, to policy details, since members will test whether your writing is grounded in schemes and laws.
Face a board like this one, with your own DAF
Our AI mock interview reads your DAF and questions you the way a real board does, then scores every answer.
Start a mock interviewMore from the Raj Shukla board
See all →CSE 2025 · interviewed 6 January, forenoon
- ChairIs Hyderabad developing along the lines of Bengaluru and Mumbai, or is it following its own path?
- ↳How is Hyderabad different from Bengaluru and Mumbai?
- ↳What is Genome Valley?
- ChairWhy isn't Hyderabad attracting much investment?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 11/12/25
- ChairWhere is current geopolitics heading, and what are its implications for the world?
- ↳Do you think China is rising, or has it already risen?
- M1Why are Pakistan and Afghanistan fighting?
- M1How do you see the recent visit of an Afghan minister to India? Should India recognise the Afghan government?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 6th January, afternoon
- ChairWhy did you decide so late to join the civil services?
- ChairWhat is India's status in aerospace capacity?
- ↳What should we do about these aerospace problems?
- ChairHow is IIT Kanpur faring in aerospace?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 10/02/2026
- ChairHyderabad is your home city. What do cities provide, and what role do they play in a country's development?
- ↳Can Indian cities ever reach the level of cities like London?
- ↳Why are cities failing to attract talent? A defence startup wanted to set up in Noida, but talent preferred Bengaluru for its schools.
- ChairR&D is important. How can India increase it?
