UPSC CSE 2023 interview, Raj Shukla board
How the board approached it
The board ran through civil services choice, then moved to taxation, healthcare, rural credit, self-help books, and AI. It questioned mostly through rapid follow-ups and counters, often cutting short long answers and pushing the candidate toward a different angle.
ChairChairman
- 1
Where are you from?
Personal background - 2
What are you doing these days?
Personal background - 3
Why didn't you fill the IFS option?
Civil services choice - 4
Foreign service is very popular, and IFS officers get a lot of recognition. Why don't you want to join it?
Civil services choice - ↳
You could be a good asset for external affairs. Why don't you want to go there?
Follow-upCivil services choice - ↳
IAS officers can work in the external affairs ministry, so why not specialise in foreign affairs?
Follow-upCivil services choice - 5
A famous writer said he did not let his schooling hinder his education. What is your opinion?
Education - 6
Why is it that students today have so many exams and no free time?
EducationCandidate: Gave a long answer on the heavy exam load and lack of free time.
- ↳
We had plenty of free time to think. If you are stuck with tests, what will you innovate?
Follow-upEducation - ↳
Even micro-credential courses have tests at the end, so what is your point?
Follow-upEducation - 7
Even in IITs, little research happens and rankings are low. What do you say?
Higher education: IITs - 8
If you disagree with ranking parameters, do you still think the overall situation in India is fine?
Higher education: IITs - ↳
So you are optimistic about the direction the country is heading in?
Follow-upHigher education: IITs
M1Member 1
- 9
Why is the tax base in India low?
TaxationCandidate: Gave a long answer on the low tax base.
- 10
Why is tax compliance low?
TaxationCandidate: Gave a long answer on compliance.
- 11
In the US people fear the IRS, unlike in India. What is your opinion?
Taxation - ↳
Why shouldn't fear be used to increase tax compliance?
Follow-upTaxation - ↳
What existing measures can improve tax compliance?
Follow-upTaxation - 12
What is the difference between progressive and regressive taxation?
Taxation - 13
What in your view should be the ideal share of direct and indirect taxes?
Taxation
M2Member 2
- 14
What is green accounting?
Green accounting - ↳
Why should green accounting be done?
Follow-upGreen accounting - 15
If measuring helps control and regulate, why shouldn't accountants stick to their job and leave climate change to experts?
Green accounting - 16
Do you prefer public or private hospitals?
HealthcareCandidate: Gave a long answer on healthcare, public and private hospitals.
- ↳
Choice is good, but are you satisfied with the current state of healthcare?
Follow-upHealthcare - 17
What would you say if all taxpayers were denied government healthcare benefits because they are well off?
Healthcare - 18
Why do microfinance institutions succeed in rural areas where traditional banks do not?
Rural creditCandidate: Gave a long answer on rural credit.
- ↳
Almost every village has at least one traditional bank. How do you explain this?
Follow-upRural credit - ↳
Microfinance institutions charge high interest rates, yet they still succeed. Why?
Follow-upRural credit
M3Member 3
- 19
Which self-help books have you read recently?
Self-help books - ↳
Which is your favourite among them?
Follow-upSelf-help books - 20
What is the meaning of 'atomic' in Atomic Habits?
Self-help books - ↳
Can you summarise Atomic Habits?
Follow-upSelf-help books - 21
Does the rising popularity of self-help books mean people lack inner motivation?
Self-help booksCandidate: Gave a long answer on this; the board cut me short.
- ↳
Does this mean people are facing mental health problems?
Follow-upMental health - 22
What do you understand by a society with more doctors, lawyers and politicians?
Society and professions - ↳
Prevention by doctors is fine, but what about lawyers?
Follow-upSociety and professions - ↳
What about politicians?
Follow-upSociety and professions - 23
What is emotional intelligence?
Emotional intelligence - 24
Will AI replace jobs?
AI and employmentCandidate: Gave a long answer on AI and jobs.
- ↳
But can AI not replace one specific sector?
Follow-upAI and employment
M4Member 4
- 25
You worked as a badminton coach before, didn't you?
Badminton coaching - ↳
Were you preparing for civil services at the same time?
Follow-upBadminton coaching - 26
Taking the earlier AI discussion forward, what role could AI play in mental healthcare?
AI in mental healthcare - ↳
You said measuring leads to better regulation. If we measure responses of the best mental health professionals and feed that data to AI, could it give accurate advice?
Follow-upAI in mental healthcare - 27
Do you know any concept about a future where AI does everything and people have nothing to do?
Future of workCandidate: Gave a long answer on a futuristic scenario with AI doing all work.
- ↳
In such a scenario, what do you think about Universal Basic Income?
Follow-upUniversal Basic Income - 28
What is Universal Basic Income?
Universal Basic Income - ↳
How would you feel about a scenario where UBI covers basic needs and AI does all productive work?
Follow-upUniversal Basic Income
What to take from this interview
- ✓Keep answers to the point, since the board repeatedly cut in and redirected long monologues.
- ✓Be ready to justify the choice of IAS over IFS and the reasons for not opting for foreign affairs.
- ✓Prepare current, concrete positions on AI, UBI, and taxation, because the board probed each one with follow-up counters.
Face a board like this one, with your own DAF
Our AI mock interview reads your DAF and questions you the way a real board does, then scores every answer.
Start a mock interviewMore from the Raj Shukla board
See all →CSE 2025 · interviewed 6 January, forenoon
- ChairIs Hyderabad developing along the lines of Bengaluru and Mumbai, or is it following its own path?
- ↳How is Hyderabad different from Bengaluru and Mumbai?
- ↳What is Genome Valley?
- ChairWhy isn't Hyderabad attracting much investment?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 11/12/25
- ChairWhere is current geopolitics heading, and what are its implications for the world?
- ↳Do you think China is rising, or has it already risen?
- M1Why are Pakistan and Afghanistan fighting?
- M1How do you see the recent visit of an Afghan minister to India? Should India recognise the Afghan government?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 6th January, afternoon
- ChairWhy did you decide so late to join the civil services?
- ChairWhat is India's status in aerospace capacity?
- ↳What should we do about these aerospace problems?
- ChairHow is IIT Kanpur faring in aerospace?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 10/02/2026
- ChairHyderabad is your home city. What do cities provide, and what role do they play in a country's development?
- ↳Can Indian cities ever reach the level of cities like London?
- ↳Why are cities failing to attract talent? A defence startup wanted to set up in Noida, but talent preferred Bengaluru for its schools.
- ChairR&D is important. How can India increase it?
