UPSC CSE 2023 interview, Raj Shukla board
How the board approached it
The board pressed hard on the candidate's choice to skip the IFS and then on the candidate's own long monologues about education, taxation, healthcare, and AI. Questioning was largely rapid follow-up challenges that cut short answers and asked the candidate to defend or reconsider each point.
ChairChairman
- 1
Where are you from?
Background - 2
What are you doing these days?
Background - 3
Why didn't you fill the IFS form?
IFS choice - 4
IFS officers and S. Jaishankar are very popular. Why don't you want to join the IFS?
IFS choice - ↳
You could be a good asset to external affairs. Why don't you want to go?
Follow-upIFS choice - ↳
IAS officers can work in external affairs, but why not specialise in foreign affairs?
Follow-upIFS choice - 5
Mark Twain said he did not let his schooling hinder his education. What is your opinion?
Education - ↳
You spoke at length about exams and no free time. Why has this scenario arisen?
Follow-upEducation - ↳
We had plenty of free time to think. If you are stuck with tests, what will you innovate?
Follow-upEducation - ↳
Micro-credential courses also have tests at the end. What do you say to that?
Follow-upEducation - 6
Even IITs do little research and rank low. What is your view?
IIT and research - ↳
If you disagree with the ranking parameters, do you consider the overall scenario in India fine?
Follow-upHigher education in India - ↳
So you are optimistic about the direction India is heading in?
Follow-upIndia's direction
M1Member 1
- 7
You said the tax base is low. What are the reasons?
Taxation: tax base - 8
You said tax compliance is low. What are the reasons?
Taxation: compliance - 9
In the US people fear the IRS, unlike in India. What is your opinion?
IRS and tax compliance - ↳
Why shouldn't fear be used to increase tax compliance?
Follow-upIRS and tax compliance - ↳
What existing measures improve tax compliance?
Follow-upTaxation: compliance - 10
What is the difference between progressive and regressive taxation?
Taxation: concepts - 11
What in your view should be the ideal share of direct and indirect taxes?
Taxation: direct vs indirect
M2Member 2
- 12
What is green accounting?
Green accounting - ↳
Why should green accounting be done?
Follow-upGreen accounting - ↳
Measuring to control and regulate is fine, but why shouldn't accountants stick to their job and leave climate change to experts?
Follow-upGreen accounting - 13
Do you prefer public hospitals or private hospitals?
Healthcare - ↳
Choice is good, but are you satisfied with the current state of healthcare?
Follow-upHealthcare - ↳
What would you say if taxpayers were denied government healthcare benefits because they are well-off?
Follow-upHealthcare and taxpayers - 14
Why do microfinance institutions succeed in rural areas when traditional banks do not?
Rural credit - ↳
Almost every village has at least one traditional bank. How do you respond?
Follow-upRural credit - ↳
MFIs charge high interest rates and still succeed. Why?
Follow-upRural credit
M3Member 3
- 15
Which self-help books have you read recently?
Self-help books - ↳
Which is your favourite?
Follow-upSelf-help books - 16
What does 'atomic' mean in Atomic Habits?
Atomic Habits - ↳
Can you summarise Atomic Habits?
Follow-upAtomic Habits - 17
Does the popularity of self-help books mean people lack inner motivation?
Self-help books and motivation - ↳
Does this mean people are having mental health problems?
Follow-upMental health - 18
What do you understand by a society with more doctors, lawyers and politicians?
Society and professions - ↳
Prevention by doctors is fine, but what about lawyers?
Follow-upSociety and professions - ↳
What about politicians?
Follow-upSociety and professions - 19
What is emotional intelligence?
Emotional intelligence - 20
Does this mean AI will replace jobs?
AI and employment - ↳
But can AI replace one specific sector?
Follow-upAI and employment
M4Member 4
- 21
You worked as a badminton coach before. Is that right?
Badminton coaching - ↳
Were you preparing for civil services at the same time?
Follow-upBadminton coaching - 22
Taking the previous member's AI discussion forward, what role could AI play in mental healthcare?
AI in mental healthcare - ↳
You said measuring leads to better regulation. If we feed responses of top mental healthcare professionals into AI, could it give accurate advice?
Follow-upAI in mental healthcare - 23
In a futuristic scenario where AI does everything and people have nothing to do, do you know any concept that describes this?
Future of work - ↳
In such a scenario, what do you think about Universal Basic Income?
Follow-upUniversal Basic Income - ↳
What is Universal Basic Income?
Follow-upUniversal Basic Income - ↳
How would you feel about a scenario where UBI covers basic amenities for all and AI does the productive work?
Follow-upUniversal Basic Income
What to take from this interview
- ✓Keep answers short and direct, since the board repeatedly cut in and re-asked the same point.
- ✓Be ready to defend an opinion when the board challenges it, and concede a valid point where appropriate.
- ✓Have a clear, balanced stance on the IFS decision and on AI's impact on jobs, since both were probed from several angles.
Face a board like this one, with your own DAF
Our AI mock interview reads your DAF and questions you the way a real board does, then scores every answer.
Start a mock interviewMore from the Raj Shukla board
See all →CSE 2025 · interviewed 6 January, forenoon
- ChairIs Hyderabad developing along the lines of Bengaluru and Mumbai, or is it following its own path?
- ↳How is Hyderabad different from Bengaluru and Mumbai?
- ↳What is Genome Valley?
- ChairWhy isn't Hyderabad attracting much investment?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 11/12/25
- ChairWhere is current geopolitics heading, and what are its implications for the world?
- ↳Do you think China is rising, or has it already risen?
- M1Why are Pakistan and Afghanistan fighting?
- M1How do you see the recent visit of an Afghan minister to India? Should India recognise the Afghan government?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 6th January, afternoon
- ChairWhy did you decide so late to join the civil services?
- ChairWhat is India's status in aerospace capacity?
- ↳What should we do about these aerospace problems?
- ChairHow is IIT Kanpur faring in aerospace?
CSE 2025 · interviewed 10/02/2026
- ChairHyderabad is your home city. What do cities provide, and what role do they play in a country's development?
- ↳Can Indian cities ever reach the level of cities like London?
- ↳Why are cities failing to attract talent? A defence startup wanted to set up in Noida, but talent preferred Bengaluru for its schools.
- ChairR&D is important. How can India increase it?
