UPPSC PCS - 2014
Consider the following statement and select the correct answer from the conculsions: Statements: All knowledge is god All knowledge is difficult. Conclusions:
Year Asked: 2014
Correct Answer
B. Some good thing are difficult
Detailed Explanation
The first statement reads 'All knowledge is good' ('god' is a typo). The second is 'All knowledge is difficult'. Knowledge sits inside both the good circle and the difficult circle, so those two circles must overlap. That overlap gives 'some good things are difficult', which is the only conclusion that follows.
Why the others fail:
- A) Reverses the premise. Knowledge being difficult does not make every difficult thing knowledge. The converse of a universal statement is not valid.
- B) Correct. A common middle term with two universal affirmative premises (AAA) yields only a particular affirmative conclusion about the outer terms, here 'some good things are difficult'.
- C) Overgeneralises. Only knowledge is shown to be difficult. Nothing says every good thing is difficult.
- D) Introduces 'easy' and 'not good', which no premise mentions.
Core concept: categorical syllogism and the limits of conversion. The same discipline of avoiding unwarranted generalisation matters in GS-IV case studies and in essay arguments.
Trap: Choosing C because 'all knowledge' seems to carry over to 'all good things'. Universal premises about a shared middle term only license 'some' for the outer terms.
This question appeared in UPPCS 2014 GS Paper 2.
Contact Information
Phone / WhatsApp
+91 8826907483Student Queries
support@collectorbabu.com