UPPSC PCS - 2014
Which one of the following is the correct comparative from of the given sentence? “You are as big a fool as a donkey”?
Year Asked: 2014
Correct Answer
C. A donkey is not a bigger fool than you.
Detailed Explanation
The original sentence expresses equality: you and the donkey are equally foolish, as shown by the 'as ... as' construction. The standard transformation converts this positive equality into a negative comparative with the subject and object swapped. So 'A donkey is not a bigger fool than you' means the donkey is not more foolish than you, which leaves you at least as foolish as the donkey. That matches the original, so C is correct.
- A says the donkey is less foolish than you, which makes you more foolish. That turns the equality into a claim of superiority.
- B has the same flaw. 'Not as big a fool as you' places the donkey below you, again asserting that you are the bigger fool.
- D reverses the meaning completely by making the donkey the bigger fool.
The core concept is the conversion of degrees of comparison: positive equality with 'as ... as' can be restated as a negative comparative with 'not ... than'. This is a staple of the English language component of PCS papers, and the same logic applies to sentences such as 'He is as wise as he is old' type transformations.
Trap: Candidates choose B because it looks like a direct negation of 'as ... as'. They miss that the original asserts equality, not superiority, and that the subject and object must be swapped in the restated form.
This question appeared in UPPCS 2014 GS Paper 2.
Contact Information
Phone / WhatsApp
+91 8826907483Student Queries
support@collectorbabu.com