UPPSC PCS - 2016
A Bill for the purpose of creating a new State in India must be passed by
Year Asked: 2016
Correct Answer
B. A simple majority in Parliament
Detailed Explanation
The correct answer is B. A bill to create a new State is passed by a simple majority in Parliament. Article 3 empowers Parliament to form new States and alter boundaries or names of existing ones by law. Article 4 clarifies that such a law is not to be treated as an amendment under Article 368, so the special majority and ratification process do not apply.
- Option A is wrong: State ratification is required only for amendments under Article 368 that affect the matters listed in the proviso, such as the Union's representation in Parliament. Article 3 needs no ratification by States.
- Option C is wrong: A two-thirds majority is needed only for constitutional amendments under Article 368. Article 4 expressly excludes reorganisation laws from that route.
- Option D is wrong: Since B is correct, "None of the above" cannot be right.
The President must refer the bill to the concerned State legislature for its views, but those views are not binding. This is a key feature of the Union's dominance in territorial reorganisation. Telangana (2014) and Ladakh (2019, as a Union Territory) show how this works. For Mains, it links to the debate on federalism and whether the Centre's power to reshape States weakens the federal bargain.
Trap: Aspirants confuse Article 3 with Article 368 and assume the two-thirds plus ratification rule applies to every change to the Constitution. Remember that Article 4 specifically keeps reorganisation laws outside Article 368.
This question appeared in UPPCS 2016 GS Paper 1.
Contact Information
Phone / WhatsApp
+91 8826907483Student Queries
support@collectorbabu.com