UPPSC PCS - 2020
What is the work of a good gardener?
Year Asked: 2020
Correct Answer
B. To help each plant to put forth the essential quality of its own
Detailed Explanation
The correct answer is B. A good gardener does not make a plant into something else. He creates conditions (soil, water, light, protection from weeds and pests) in which the plant unfolds the qualities already present in its seed. A rose grows as a rose, and a mango tree as a mango tree.
- A is wrong because watering is only one input. Helping a plant take water is a means, not the purpose of gardening.
- C is wrong because every plant grows by its own nature anyway. Growth alone does not say what kind of growth is desired or what is distinctive about the plant.
- D is wrong because being green and healthy is a symptom of good care, not the aim. A healthy plant can still fail to express its own nature.
The core concept is education as nurturing, not imposing. The gardener is the model for a teacher who draws out the child's potential instead of moulding every learner to one template. This idea recurs in Sri Aurobindo's educational thought and in Mains answers on child-centred learning, the National Education Policy 2020 and the role of the teacher.
Trap: aspirants pick C because 'help to grow' sounds closest to the idea. The question is about the quality that is specific to each plant, which is the point of option B.
This question appeared in UPPCS 2020 CSAT Paper.
Contact Information
Phone / WhatsApp
+91 8826907483Student Queries
support@collectorbabu.com